The Law Library of Victoria service is totally digital while the Supreme Court Library is temporarily closed. Enjoy photos of the grand space under the dome by following us on Instagram @lawlibraryvic
- Library Services
Vyater, Yan v The Queen
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Conviction - Trafficking methylamphetamine, trafficking ephedrine, possession of substances, materials and equipment for the purpose of manufacturing drug of dependence - Circumstantial case - Expert evidence - DNA evidence on glove - Low likelihood ratio - Presentation of DNA evidence - Juror understanding of probabilistic evidence - Whether probative value of evidence outweighed by risk of unfair prejudice - Probative value high - Any risk of prejudice cured by jury directions - No error by trial judge in ruling evidence admissible - R v Doheny and Adams  1 Cr App R 369, R v Berry (2007) 17 VR 153,  VSCA 202, R v Guingab  VSC 256 considered - Evidence Act 2008 s 137.
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Conviction - Applicant convicted of trafficking ephedrine by preparing it for manufacture of methylamphetamine - Whether charge invalid at law - Extended definition of 'trafficking' - 'Preparation' form of trafficking confined to preparation of drug for trafficking in that drug - Appeal allowed - Conviction set aside - Substituted conviction for possession of substance for purpose of trafficking - Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 ss 70, 71AA, 71AC, 71A.
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Conviction - Evidence - Police interview - Applicant gave address prior to caution - Obligation to administer caution before 'questioning' - No error in admitting evidence - Crimes Act 1958 s 464A, Evidence Act 2008 s 139.