The Law Library of Victoria service is totally digital while the Supreme Court Library is temporarily closed. Enjoy photos of the grand space under the dome by following us on Instagram @lawlibraryvic
- Library Services
Lyons, Christine Ann v The Queen; Lyons, Ronald v The Queen
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Conviction - Murder - Attempted murder - Joint criminal enterprise - Victim mother of four young children - First applicant unable to bear children - Motive to kill victim to enable first applicant to assume care of victim's children - Attempt by first and second applicants to kill victim by drugging with sedatives - Attempt unsuccessful - Victim violently bashed to death by co-offender on instruction by first applicant - Second applicant assisted co-offender to dispose of deceased's body - First applicant convicted of murder and attempted murder - Second applicant acquitted of murder, but convicted of attempted murder and assist offender (murder) - Whether verdicts unsafe or unsatisfactory - Co-offender undertook to give evidence against first and second applicants - Whether co-offender's evidence capable of being accepted - Path to conviction open on totality of evidence - Whether first applicant's conviction inconsistent with second applicant's acquittal on charge of murder - Verdicts not inconsistent - Applications for leave to appeal against conviction refused.