The Law Library of Victoria service is totally digital while the Supreme Court Library is temporarily closed. Enjoy photos of the grand space under the dome by following us on Instagram @lawlibraryvic
- Library Services
Flynn, Simon (a pseudonym) v The Queen
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Conviction - Applicant tried on indictment containing five charges of having, on three separate dates, raped his wife - Acquittal on charges 1-3, but conviction on charges 4 and 5 - Applicant's eldest son intervened in offending giving rise to charges 4 and 5 - Eldest son gave evidence against applicant by way of VARE and special hearing - Whether verdicts unsafe or unsatisfactory - Whether two jurors, separately, ought to have been discharged, for different reasons - Whether VARE tapes of applicant's children ought to have been exhibits - Whether judge correctly directed jury that evidence of what eldest son told his brother should be disregarded - Whether impermissible cross-examination of applicant - Whether substantial miscarriage of justice - Verdicts open to jury - No substantial miscarriage of justice - Leave to appeal against conviction refused.
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Sentence - Two charges of digital rape - Sentence of 6 years' imprisonment on each charge - 2 years' cumulation - Total effective sentence of 8 years' imprisonment with non-parole period of 5 years - Whether sentence manifestly excessive - Rapes occurred within moments of each other - Single transaction rule - Order for cumulation manifestly excessive - Leave to appeal against sentence granted - Appeal allowed - Applicant resentenced to total effective term of 6 years and 6 months with non-parole period of 4 years.