The Law Library of Victoria service is totally digital while the Supreme Court Library is temporarily closed. Enjoy photos of the grand space under the dome by following us on Instagram
- Library Services
Chamma, Osman v The Queen; El Houli, Amir v The Queen
CRIMINAL LAW - Appeal - Sentence - Sentencing procedure - Principle of parity - Approach to sentencing co-offenders - Theft of a motor vehicle - Conduct endangering serious injury - Damaging property - Verdins considerations - Weighting of mitigating factors - Comparison of mitigating factors of co-offenders - Seriousness of theft of a motor vehicle - Impact of value of property on seriousness of theft - Impact of value of damage on seriousness of offence of damaging property - Weighting of criminal history in sentencing calculus - Comparison of criminal histories of co-offenders - Comparison of personal circumstances of co-offenders - Comparison of seriousness of individual charges in sentencing co-offenders - Impact of institutionalisation on weight of burden of imprisonment - Leave to appeal refused; R v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 279, R v Abdul-Rasool (2008) VR 586, McPhee v The Queen  VSCA 156, Ah-Kau v The Queen  VSCA 296, Nipoe v The Queen  VSCA 137 considered - Crimes Act 1958 ss 23, 74(1) 197(1), Criminal Procedure Act 2009 s 280(1)(b).